Los Angeles residents sue HUD to block rule requiring immigration-status proof in public housing

Los Angeles nonprofit law firm Public Counsel filed suit in federal court late Monday, challenging a Department of Housing and Urban Development rule that requires all federally assisted housing residents to prove citizenship or eligible immigration status, effective December 14; the plaintiffs say HUD has no authority to unilaterally change a policy in place for nearly 30 years.
Los Angeles nonprofit law firm Public Counsel filed suit in federal court late Monday (November 16), challenging a Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) rule set to take effect December 14. The rule requires every resident of federally funded housing to prove citizenship or eligible immigration status, ending a nearly 30-year arrangement that allowed mixed-status families to live together in assisted housing. The plaintiffs ask the court to postpone the rule's effective date, bar enforcement in California's Central District, and declare the rule unlawful.
Rule takes effect December 14; about 79,300 people affected nationwide
The rule was published November 12 in the Federal Register (91 FR 72978). It requires every member of an assisted household to prove status, removes age exemptions and eliminates the option to decline to claim a status; prorated assistance would continue only temporarily while status checks are pending. HUD estimates that, as of 2024, 79,300 members of mixed-status families lived in public housing nationwide, including 7,190 households in California; the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles says 1,709 mixed-status families — about 7,700 people — currently receive assistance in the city. HUD further estimates that about 19,810 mixed families would be eligible for a temporary deferral of termination, and about 990 households would contest and face formal eviction proceedings.
Plaintiffs: the power to change the policy belongs to Congress, not HUD
The three plaintiffs are all Los Angeles public housing residents, identified only by their initials. One, a 24-year-old pharmacy technician identified as J.L., has lived for 15 years in a Housing Authority unit with two US-citizen siblings and undocumented parents. The plaintiffs argue that HUD lacks the authority to change the policy by regulation and that the power belongs to Congress, which enacted the original provisions — Section 214 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1980. The suit was also brought on behalf of the People Organized for Westside Renewal and Union de Vecinos. Kathryn Eidmann, Public Counsel's president and CEO, said: 'For 30 years, mixed-status families have lived together in public housing and Section 8 homes.'
HUD secretary: the rule simply enforces federal law
HUD Secretary Scott Turner responded that the rule 'fully implements federal law' and 'guarantees only American citizens and certain eligible noncitizens will reside in HUD-funded housing.' The rule stems from a proposal first made in 2019 and was finalized after years of dispute. The Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, which oversees more than 67,000 households, said it is reviewing the regulation's operational requirements and timelines and would 'pursue all avenues' to address the change.
(Public housing in Los Angeles. File photo, image: Secret Los Angeles.)
N環球 
💬 Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!