N環球 N GLOBE
Canada Technology

Canada's Bill C-22 goes before Senate as Apple, Meta and Google push for rewrite

· N GLOBE

Canada's Senate national security committee holds three hearings on the Lawful Access Act (Bill C-22) on Monday, November 16, with Meta, Signal and Tailscale executives testifying, as Apple, Meta and Alphabet lobby Ottawa to rewrite provisions they say threaten encryption and user privacy.

Canada's Senate national security committee holds three hearings on the controversial Lawful Access Act (Bill C-22) in Ottawa on Monday, November 16, starting at 4 p.m. ET. Executives from Meta, Signal and Tailscale will testify, while Apple, Meta and Alphabet mount a last-ditch lobbying push to have Ottawa rewrite the bill's most contested provisions before it becomes law.

The bill would require providers to build lawful-access capabilities

Bill C-22 was introduced on March 12, 2026, by Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree, passed the House of Commons at third reading on June 18, and completed second reading in the Senate on October 22, when it was referred to the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs. It has not received royal assent. Part 2 of the bill would let the public safety minister issue confidential orders requiring electronic service providers to build lawful-access capabilities, and regulations could require core providers to retain user metadata for up to six months — the House already cut that period from one year to six months, and ministerial orders now require approval from the Intelligence Commissioner.

Ottawa has already amended the bill after objections from Apple and Google, adding safeguards against requirements that create systemic security vulnerabilities, and the government says the bill does not create encryption backdoors. Tech companies argue the provisions could still force providers to weaken encryption and build intercept systems. A recent U.S. precedent alarms the industry: the China-linked hacking group Salt Typhoon breached American telecom carriers' lawful-intercept systems.

Meta calls weaker protections a red line; Signal threatens to leave Canada

Bloomberg Law reported on November 16 that lobbyists and executives from Meta, Apple and Alphabet are pressing the Carney government to strip or rewrite the metadata-retention clause. Meta's Canadian policy chief Rachel Curran called weaker protections a "red line"; encrypted messaging app Signal has threatened to leave Canada, and Proton is reconsidering its expansion plans. In September, more than 20 technology companies and industry groups wrote jointly to the public safety and industry ministers seeking further amendments. Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne has taken a more measured position.

Three panels today: scholars, civil liberties groups, then industry

Today's hearings run from 4 to 7 p.m. ET in Room W110, 1 Wellington Street, Ottawa, in three panels. The first panel (4–5 p.m.) hears scholars Aaron Shull, Carleton University's Leah West and the University of Ottawa's Michael Geist. The second (5–6 p.m.) hears civil liberties and internet-freedom advocates, including Tamir Israel of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, Kate Robertson of Citizen Lab and Matthew Hatfield of OpenMedia. The third (6–7 p.m.) brings industry witnesses: Meta's Rachel Curran and Robyn Greene, Signal's Udbhav Tiwari, Tailscale co-founder Avery Pennarun and David Shipley of Beauceron Security. Apple and Google are not listed among today's witnesses but are part of the broader lobbying campaign.

What happens next

The Senate committee can report the bill with or without amendments. If the Senate changes the text, the House of Commons must agree to identical wording before royal assent. The committee already heard from commissioners and the minister on November 2; today's hearings are seen as the decisive round shaping the bill's final form.

💬 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!