N環球 N GLOBE
Canada · Society

Woman dies at Port Hardy Hospital after arriving minutes after ER closed; doctors call for 24-hour emergency care

· N GLOBE

A woman in critical condition was treated in the parking lot of Port Hardy Hospital on Thursday evening, minutes after its emergency department closed at 5 p.m., and later died inside. Local doctors are calling for the ER to become a round-the-clock service as the province and health authorities review the case.

A woman in critical condition was treated in the parking lot of Port Hardy Hospital on Thursday evening, minutes after its emergency department closed at 5 p.m., and later died inside the hospital despite resuscitation efforts. British Columbia's Coroners Service is investigating the death, and Island Health and BC Emergency Health Services are reviewing the circumstances. Local doctors are calling for the emergency department to become a round-the-clock service.

Arrived minutes after closing; treated outdoors in the parking lot

According to BC Emergency Health Services, a paramedic at the hospital became aware at 5:11 p.m. on Thursday that a patient in the parking lot needed medical treatment. Two additional ambulances responded. Paramedics provided emergency treatment outdoors before transferring the patient, in critical condition, to hospital staff inside; she could not be resuscitated. Officials have not released the woman's identity or what caused the medical emergency, nor how long she was outside. North Island MLA Anna Kindy confirmed in a social media post that the deceased was a woman and offered condolences to her family.

Emergency department closes at 5 p.m. every night, for nearly four years

Port Hardy Hospital's emergency department has closed daily at 5 p.m. since early 2023 because of staffing shortages, leaving the community of just over 4,000 people near the northern tip of Vancouver Island without round-the-clock emergency care. The nearest open hospital is in Port McNeill, a 45-kilometre drive along a winding highway. Port Hardy Mayor Pat Corbett-Labatt said concentrating overnight emergency services at Port McNeill was supposed to be temporary, and that staffing shortages have forced repeated emergency department closures at hospitals across the North Island, including Port McNeill and Alert Bay. The hospital has 18 beds.

Doctor: people have died because of the closures before

Dr. Alex Nataros, a family physician with the North Island Community Health Centre, said a colleague was doing rounds inside the hospital on Thursday night and witnessed what happened. 'Frankly, it's been very upsetting,' he said. He said paramedics performed CPR outside 'for a prolonged period of time,' which he called unusual, and questioned why the woman was not taken to the nearest open hospital. He said people have died as a result of the overnight closures before — 'There's been deaths, and too many deaths,' he said. 'It's unacceptable. It's reprehensible that our emergency has been closed for almost four years.' Nataros was suspended by Island Health in 2023 from working in its emergency rooms following complaints from patients and health-care workers raising patient safety concerns; he has been an outspoken critic of the health authority's staffing decisions and is calling on the new health minister to act.

Doctors call for a permanent overnight ER; province promises review

After the death, local doctors went further, calling for Port Hardy to become a permanent overnight emergency site. Island Health said it is reviewing the circumstances of the case with BC Emergency Health Services and that it would be inappropriate to speculate on any factors that may have contributed while the review is under way. The province announced a $45-million expansion and upgrade of Port Hardy Hospital earlier this year, including improvements to its emergency department, to be completed in phases by 2029 — but has not said when the emergency department will return to 24-hour service.

New premier promised to reverse the closures

Lorne Doerkson, sworn in as B.C. premier on November 20, promised on October 5 to reverse rural emergency department closures and create a $50-million emergency fund to help rural practices recruit staff; new Health Minister Ryan Peterson faces the same pressure to deliver. Kindy, who is also the province's minister of state for rural development, said she understood emergency staff were available to respond in this case, but acknowledged it is 'not the case far too often in too many rural communities like Port Hardy that don't have 24/7 emergency care.' Port Hardy is not an isolated case: rural communities across B.C. have had emergency hours cut in recent years as staffing shortages persist, forcing patients to travel long distances for care — and after nearly four years of what was meant to be a temporary closure, residents and doctors are asking how long it will be before someone else is left outside a locked emergency department at night. (Sources: CBC British Columbia; CHEK News)

💬 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!