N環球 N GLOBE
World Politics

Top UN court rules Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, a first in 80 years

· N GLOBE

The International Court of Justice ruled on Thursday that Myanmar's military committed genocide against the Rohingya in its 2017 crackdown, with judges voting 9-6 that the campaign was carried out with intent to destroy the group — the first time in the court's 80-year history that it has held a state responsible for genocide. The court ordered Myanmar to allow refugees to return safely and to pay reparations.

The International Court of Justice ruled on Thursday (November 19) in The Hague that Myanmar's military committed genocide against the Rohingya minority in its 2017 crackdown. It is the first time in the court's 80-year history that it has held a state responsible for the crime of genocide. Judges voted 9-6 that the military's campaign was carried out with intent to destroy the Rohingya as a group.

Above: judges of the International Court of Justice attend a public hearing in The Hague on Thursday ahead of the reading of the judgment in the genocide case against Myanmar. (Photo: Jeroen Jumelet / ANP / AFP via Getty Images)

About 10,000 killed, 392 villages burned

The court estimated that about 10,000 Rohingya were killed during the weeks-long campaign in August and September 2017, including up to 2,109 children younger than five, and that 392 villages were burned in whole or in part. The violence was systematic: soldiers committed rapes and massacred women, men and children, burned villages and attacked fleeing civilians. About 700,000 Rohingya fled to Bangladesh, joining earlier refugee waves in the world's largest refugee settlement near Cox's Bazar.

Court rejects Myanmar's counterinsurgency defence

Myanmar had argued its military was conducting counterinsurgency operations against an armed group, the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army. The court said the military failed to distinguish between civilians and alleged insurgents, and that the scale and nature of the violence could not be explained by counterterrorism. "The execution of Rohingya men and boys in some locations, the widespread sexual violence, the targeting of children and babies, the methodical burning of villages, and attacks on fleeing civilians are not consistent with an intent to conduct counterinsurgency operations," said ICJ President Judge Yuji Iwasawa. The court also found that the Rohingya are a distinct ethnic group that has been discriminated against for decades and qualifies as a protected group.

Court orders safe return and reparations

The court ordered Myanmar to enable displaced Rohingya to return safely, voluntarily and with dignity, and to investigate people suspected of involvement in the crimes and prosecute them if warranted; Myanmar must also provide restitution and compensation, with the amount to be set in future proceedings. The judgment is binding on Myanmar and on all states that have ratified the 1948 Genocide Convention, but the court, which hears disputes between states, cannot enforce its decisions. It did not order Myanmar to grant citizenship to the Rohingya, saying that issue fell outside the scope of the measures being considered.

Case brought by Gambia; Canada among 11 interveners

The case was brought by Gambia in 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention, with Canada among 11 countries intervening in support. The United States had previously reached a similar conclusion: in 2022, the Biden administration formally determined that Myanmar's military had committed genocide and crimes against humanity in its 2016 and 2017 operations. Legal experts said the ruling will affect future genocide cases, including South Africa's case against Israel, particularly on questions of genocidal intent and state responsibility.

Mixed reactions

UN Secretary-General António Guterres called the ruling "a powerful recognition of the Rohingya victims of genocide" and said it reaffirms that "impunity for such horrific acts must not stand." International human rights organisations and UN bodies welcomed the judgment. The US State Department told NPR on Thursday that it supports Rohingya refugees but raised doubts about the court, saying "the proper interpretation of the Genocide Convention is of paramount importance, as is preventing politicization of the ICJ," and that it is studying the decision. US Ambassador to the UN Mike Waltz wrote online in October that the ICJ must not be allowed to lower the legal threshold for proving genocide. Myanmar's military-backed government had not responded to the ruling at the time of writing.

Prospects for return remain bleak

The order to enable displaced Rohingya to return runs into a hard reality: Rakhine state is now controlled by the ethnic Rakhine armed group the Arakan Army, whose conflict with the military has ravaged the region, and Rohingya in Myanmar and in the camps are threatened by multiple armed groups. Su Mon, a senior analyst at the independent conflict monitor Armed Conflict Location & Event Data, said that unless the broader conflict dynamics in Rakhine improve or credible guarantees of safety are secured from all armed actors, the prospects for displaced Rohingya to return home remain bleak. Many in the camps are on the verge of acute famine because of aid shortfalls and a junta blockade.

Survivors: recognition alone is not enough

Ma Roga Bibi, an 18-year-old Rohingya who fled Maungdaw township in northern Rakhine state at age nine and now lives in the world's largest refugee settlement in Bangladesh, said: "I feel wonderful and grateful. It was an emotional, historic day." She added: "Recognition alone is not enough. We need justice, accountability, and the opportunity to return home with dignity." She wants to be a doctor, adding: "In our Rohingya community, there is no girl doctor."

Sources: NPR, the International Court of Justice, the United Nations, The Associated Press.

💬 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!