New York beats Trump administration in court over $73.5M highway funds

The Second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration could not withhold more than $73 million in federal highway funding from New York, because the requirement it cited did not exist in the regulations at the time.
A three-judge panel of the Second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on Friday that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) could not withhold more than $73 million in federal highway funding from New York for fiscal 2027. The court found the federal government sought to enforce a requirement that did not exist under the regulations in effect at the time. New York Attorney General Letitia James and Governor Kathy Hochul said in a joint statement that New York had once again defeated the administration's "endless quest to hurt New Yorkers." (Sources: Newsweek / Second Circuit ruling)
The dispute: immigrant commercial licences
The dispute stems from New York's practice of issuing nondomiciled commercial driver's licences valid for five years on issuance and eight years on renewal, even when a driver's immigration documents expired sooner. New York has about 32,600 holders of nondomiciled commercial licences and learner's permits, roughly 7 percent of the state's active commercial licences and permits. FMCSA began reviewing New York's licensing programme in July 2025 and issued a final determination in April 2026, saying it would withhold 4 percent of the state's federal-aid highway funding, amounting to $73,502,543; continued noncompliance could have led to as much as $147 million being withheld in subsequent years.
Court: the rules did not require it then
The court said the rules required immigrants to present valid immigration documents when applying for a commercial licence, but did not require the licence to expire when those documents did; commercial licences could generally remain valid for up to eight years. "The agency could not withhold federal funding based on a state's noncompliance with a regulatory requirement that did not exist," the court wrote. Circuit Judge Schwartz agreed with the outcome but said the case should have been decided solely on the wording of the old regulations.
Newer rule challenged separately
The court also noted that FMCSA later explicitly added restrictions linking licences to immigration documents. Under a final rule that took effect on March 16, 2026, eligibility for nondomiciled commercial licences is restricted to foreign nationals holding one of three specified nonimmigrant classifications — H-2A, H-2B and E-2 — with validity generally limited to one year or the authorised period of admission, whichever comes first. That rule is the subject of a separate legal challenge before the D.C. Circuit, and Friday's ruling did not address its legality. The funding at issue comes from the National Highway Performance Program and the Surface Transportation Block Grant Program, which support road and bridge maintenance and other transport projects.
(Photo: file photo — the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit building.)
N環球 
💬 Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!