N環球 N GLOBE
New York · Transit

Hochul Let MTA Absorb $200M Bus Funding Cut in Budget Deal, Watchdog Report Says

· N GLOBE

A Reinvent Albany report says Gov. Kathy Hochul and Mayor Zohran Mamdani's $4 billion budget deal earlier this year let New York City cut its annual payment to the MTA's bus division by $200 million; the state initially said it would cover the money, but the transit agency ended up absorbing the loss — nearly wiping out the revenue expected from next year's fare hike and complicating Mamdani's free-bus promise.

A report from Albany watchdog group Reinvent Albany says Gov. Kathy Hochul and Mayor Zohran Mamdani let New York City cut its annual payment to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's bus division by $200 million in a budget deal earlier this year; Hochul initially said the state would cover the money from its budget, but the transit agency ended up absorbing the loss itself. The report was covered by Streetsblog on Monday (November 16).

$200 million inside a $4 billion deal

On May 12, Hochul and Mamdani announced '$4 billion in gap-closing support' from the state to close the city's budget gap. Neither said at the time that the package included forgiving or deferring $200 million of the city's regular payment to the MTA. The report says the announcement 'made it sound like the $4 billion was new state assistance' to the city. The city's May 2026 Financial Plan Reconciliation, meanwhile, lists the $200 million in city 'savings' as 'State Aid for MTA.'

Two comptrollers reversed course; MTA absorbed the loss in July

Through the spring, everyone — including the city and state comptrollers — said the state would indeed pay the city's $200-million contribution to MTA Bus. City Comptroller Mark Levine described it in his May monthly economic newsletter as a 'one-time shift to the state'; state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli said much the same a month later. But by late June, Levine revealed that the change 'was not included in the State's Enacted Budget and must be made in the MTA financial plan.'

In its preliminary budget issued in July, the MTA said it would absorb the $200 million loss, writing that the budget 'reflects a corresponding one-time reduction in the expected city subsidy reimbursement, which will be covered by MTA resources,' while maintaining current bus service levels. Rachael Fauss, Reinvent Albany's senior policy analyst and the report's author, said the MTA Bus aid is supposed to be protected under a 2004 agreement between New York City and the MTA: 'The MTA is not the piggybank of the state and the city whenever they need to find money to pay for some other priority.' She added: 'The MTA is getting $200 million less than it is supposed to from New York City — all while the governor could claim credit for helping the city to balance its budget.' 'None of this was written down in the state budget agreement. We had to dig through the financial records to even figure out what happened here.'

Free-bus promise under pressure

The report says the $200-million loss more or less wipes out the revenue the MTA anticipated from next year's 4-percent fare and toll hike, making it harder for Mamdani to deliver his signature promise of buses that are both fast and free. Betsy Plum, executive director of the Riders Alliance, said: 'Raiding public transit funds or trying to balance the city budget on riders' backs makes New York less affordable and erodes trust in our government.' Streetsblog said it reached out to City Hall and the governor's office on Friday and had not heard back.

Sources: Streetsblog, November 16, 2026; Reinvent Albany report; MTA preliminary budget.

💬 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!