Canada halted work on thermal coal export ban on verbal political direction, officials tell MPs

Environment Canada officials told a Commons committee the decision to stop work on banning thermal coal exports came from the political level and was conveyed verbally; an audit found the work stopped in November 2024 without any public notice, despite Canada's 2021 pledge to ban the exports by 2030.
Environment Canada officials told Parliament on November 19 that the decision to stop work on banning thermal coal exports came from the "political level" — and was conveyed only verbally. The officials acknowledged the department could not explain why the Liberal government made the call.
Testimony before the committee
Megan Nichols, the department's assistant deputy minister of environmental protection, told the House of Commons environment committee the stop-work decision was communicated verbally. She said the department has committed to explaining the decision in its formal response to the environment commissioner's report, adding: "We were told to reallocate our resources to other priorities." Nichols did not say who gave the direction or explain the reasoning behind it.
Audit: work stopped early, never announced
The testimony follows an October report by the Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development. It found the department spent about three years studying how to implement the ban, then halted all work in November 2024, after lobbying from the coal industry. There was no record of any formal direction to stop, and no public announcement that the work had ended, even though Canada's commitment to the ban remained in place. The halt was only formalized in August 2025, when the federal government was seeking cost savings, the report said.
The audit also found that thermal coal exports shipped from Canada in 2025 remained above 2021 levels, the year Canada made its commitment, and that about 61 percent of those exports originated in the United States. Environment Canada never informed Global Affairs Canada of the decision to stop work.
A pledge out of step with the record
Canada committed in 2021 to banning thermal coal exports by 2030 and co-chairs the Powering Past Coal Alliance with the United Kingdom, which pushes countries to phase out coal-fired power. Critics say Canada has largely phased out burning thermal coal at home while continuing to export it abroad — a contradiction the commissioner's report said was compounded by the department's failure to assess the consequences of stopping work or to consult affected parties.
Reaction
Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin has said the decision not to proceed was made by her predecessor, Steven Guilbeault, and that she inherited an arrangement in which the work was already not going ahead; she added the new government is "open to next steps." The government has so far refused to say whether it remains committed to the 2030 ban, saying only that it is considering its next steps. Environmental groups have urged Ottawa to reaffirm the ban or step down from chairing the Powering Past Coal Alliance; Bloc Québécois climate critic Patrick Bonin has taken the same position.
(Photo: The Canadian Press; file photo of a coal export terminal)
N環球 
💬 Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!